Showing posts with label Olympus body cap lens. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Olympus body cap lens. Show all posts

November 15, 2013


Eventhough its been less than a week since the BCLmacros discovery, I have enjoyed using this lens so far and I hope it attracts a following. Therefore, I put together a short list of tips to "jump start" those planning on converting their body cap lens to the BLCmacro. I think that this dedicated macro alternative will interest people for the same reasons that they enjoy using the body cap lens in its native wide angle mode. Its extremely cheap, weighs next to nothing and makes your camera super portable. Also it delivers pretty good results considering this was in no way shape or form designed to be used as a macro lens. Because practice make perfect, I am sure there is still much to be learned about maximizing the BCLmacro's performance and I am a very excited guinea pig. 

I. Focus using the "rocking" method


I am a fan and follower of Robin Wong's photography blog and through his impressive macro reviews he has introduced me to the "rocking method" he uses for macro work. Here, even with the 12-50mm EM5 kit zoom or Olympus' glorious 60mm macro, he switches to manual focus mode after auto focusing before hitting the shutter button. After he switches modes he rocks back and forth and watches the in focus area change along the depth of his subject. Since the DOF in macro photography is very shallow (and less than 1cm when using the BCLmacro) this method ensures that you achieve critical focus where you want it. If you rely on auto focusing there is chance that the camera will focus on the eye of a butterfly vs it's brilliant wing pattern which you had the intention of showcasing. Auto focusing is not even an option for the BCLmacro and I have adopted this rocking method described by Robin to ensure that I am in focus before depressing my shutter button. Since the EM5-BCLmacro is extremely handheld, I usually do not necessarily have to rock my entire body back and forth, but simply move the camera in the same fashion. The concept Robin introduced still applies and when doing this it is best to be in magnify mode as you can see the changes is focus a lot easier. If you have practice manually focusing using legacy lenses I assume this will come naturally to you and focusing the BCLmacro will be easy as pie. 

II. Frame with cropping in mind


If you are like me then you will embrace all the quirks that the BCLmacro has to offer. As you can see in the photo above, these include a heavy-moderate vignette (depending on degree of modification), color fringing along the edges of the frame, and distortion. The "effects" make for a unique photo, but I am sure there will some that wish to use the BCLmacro to present a more traditional macro shot. 


If you are one of these people, it is important that you frame with cropping in mind. I have found the easiest way to do this is to enable your digital teleconverter. As discussed in "Part II" of this series, this renders the vignette, color fringing, and distortion negligible and increases your magnification to 1:1.44. Using this method you can frame your subject, toggle your magnification box to the area which you want to achieve critical focus, enable magnification mode, "rock to focus", and then depress the shutter button when you hit that sweet spot. If you shoot JPEG+RAW then you will have to crop the RAW version in Lightroom or other photo editing software. The JPEG will retain the 2x crop so you can use it as a guide.   

III. Use your kit flash


If you are like me and do not have an off camera flash (although one is on the way using guidance from the wonderful Phoblographer) the modified body cap lens is a great macro option. When using a dedicated macro lens that protrudes far from your camera body (especially true with legacy glass) one cannot use their on camera flash because of shading caused by the lens itself. To counter this you can buy a macro lighting equipment which attaches to the base of your lens or turns your camera into something out of a sci-fi movie, come up with a contraption to direct your kit flash past the camera lens or buy an off camera flash. This problem simply does not exist with the BLCmacro because the lens just barely protrudes from your camera's body. In general there are many benefits to using a flash in photography. For the BCLmacro, using a flash is important because it allows for faster shutter speeds. This in turn reduces the amount of blur and maximizes the sharpness of photos taken with this lens.  An example of this can be found in the "Money Shot" section in "Part II" of this series. Being able to use a faster shutter speed also means you can freeze motion.


For all practical purposes, you may also want to plan on using your kit flash during macro sessions with the BCLmacro because you may find something that you want to photograph which becomes shaded by your own camera because of the 7mm working distance. If you have no experience with using the kit flash or flash photography at all then do a little bit of research on the fundamentals and then canon ball into that cold swimming pool. Using the BLCmacro will certainly be a great introduction. The way I learned was to set the flash to manual and adjust the intensity depending on the exposure of your resulting photo (blown highlights = reduce flash level, everything is dark = increase flash level). If everything except your subject is black and you want more of its surroundings showing, then reduce the shutter speed (and probably the flash level too). This sort of experimentation results in a lot of chimping and trashed photos, but trial and error has pointed me in the right direction and applying it to photographs taken with the BCLmacro has been a ton of fun! 

IV. Diffuse your flash


Diffusion is important because it reduces the "harshness" of your flash. Studio photographers have come up with all sorts of flash diffusion techniques and one of the simplest is to bounce your light off of an umbrella or white wall. This effectively smooths the light and gives it a more natural look. Since my kit flash is the only thing available to me offshore and cannot be aimed at a wall or umbrella for diffusion I spent a good while contemplating how to soften it's output. By complete accident I stumbled upon the solution of diffusing using latex gloves. I had a pair left over from a while back when I had to deal with a mold issue so I cut two fingers off (thumbs-largest) and fitted them over the small flash head. If you do this make sure the glove is stretched taught across the "bulb area". Below are examples of photos taken with (right) and without (left) the latex diffuser.

FULL power
1/2 power
1/4 power
1/8 power
1/16 power
1/32 power
1/64 power
Besides me needing to badly clean my keyboard, you can see that the light in all the photos on the right is more natural looking and evenly distributed than the photos on the left. All it takes to accomplish this is a small amount of latex and I think it can really help maximize results coming from the BCLmacro. There will be some instances when you do not want a softer flash and removal of the latex is quick and easy. As soon as I can I am going to look for a box of latex finger cots to reduce the amount of waste from tearing up a latex glove.


V. Experiment during post processing

***UPDATE (11/17/2013) 

The color fringing and vignette can be excluded by cropping, but there are also other options to embrace the quirks exhibited by the BCLmacro. Besides the suggestions below, check out The Phoblographers article on color sliders and get your creative juices flowing.

1. Convert to black and white

The outcome of this will depend on how you modified your original BCL. I filed down the sides of my front lens plate and internal mount so the vignette in the above example is almost non existent. Direct conversion to black and white however gets rid of the color fringing and leaves you with a more natural looking photo.

2. Add color fringing

If you aren't into the natural look and really want to embrace this lens then add some graduated filters around your subject and create color casts that accentuate the existing color fringe. This is indeed something to save for special occasions tho as the novelty will wear off after you turn all your photos into circus performers :)

3. Add a heavy vignette  

The last option I am going to present involves creating a vignette that is larger than the area that is effected by color fringing. Of course this will only work with a certain type of photo and in my morbid example above my subject not only isolated using the vignette, but all focus is directed to the birds skull because it was highlighted using the kit flash. This overall look mimics what a flash snoot would do for a portrait photographer. As with the addition of color fringing, I can see myself using this sparingly.  

VI. Have FUN!

By all means the BCLmacro is probably not the best to use on a professional assignment due to an array of limitations. BUT using this lens can be a good way to inject some creativity into your workflow. The photos it produces are insanely unique and if you have never owned a macro lens but own a BCL this is a perfect opportunity for you to experiment with this type of photography! Just make sure to order a backup ;) I myself still have much to learn regarding macro photography and the use of the BCLmacro has made me want to dive deeper into this field. I hope this has inspired someone out there to grab their body cap lens and tiny electronics screwdriver kit and that you enjoyed the photos I have come up with so far. Thank you very much for dropping by, check back periodically for updates and additional tips =)

Sam D. 

November 14, 2013


This post will focus on the few informal tests I have run on the BCLmacro. I wanted to also present some example photos and write about using it in the field, but will save that for "Part III" because of the length of this article. Of course, I am far from qualified to rate this lens on a technical level and cannot perform tests like those you would find here, but I do have a background in science and have tried to apply the scientific method in my examples. One caveat is that I am on a seismic vessel which is basically a floating factory... we even have to wear hard hats ;) Besides the back and forth movement from being on a boat everything is CONSTANTLY vibrating. I thank the heavens for the image stabilization built into my EM5 on a daily basis. In addition, as stated in "Part I" of this series my BCL was malfunctioning before the conversion so you may get even better results =) The take home message is, digest these "tests" with a grain of salt. They are only meant as a guide to help you get started taking awesome photos with your newly modified BCL!

I. Dirty Ruler Tests


The first thing I did after putting the BLCmacro into action was to assess it's working distance. I was awed at how close I had to be to achieve focus, but the scientist in me wanted a number. My solution for testing this was to place a ruler at the base of my camera, slightly tilt it down and assess the "in focus" area.  Results of this test indicated that the working distance is about 7 cm and the DOF (in focus area) is about 5-7mm or roughly 1 cm. The photo below is a SOOC JPEG and not ideal to assess maximum sharpness because the iso equaled 1000 and shutter speed was 1/ (0.5*effective focal length) = 1/15. I have however provided a magnified view (not 100% crop) of the unedited RAW file to give a better idea of the focus at 6 vs 7 vs 8 mm. Again, this test was only done to give an indication of the working  distance and DOF, in the following section we look at optimal sharpness =)

Working distance
Magnified view
I also used my very tarnished ruler to gain a feel for the magnification of this lens.. My macro knowledge is quite limited, but it is my understanding that magnification is dependent on your sensor's width. If you have an 18mm sensor (like m4/3 cameras do) then you achieve 1:1 magnification if you are able to photograph something 18mm across. To test the BLCmacro's magnification, I taped my ruler to a thick sketch journal so that it was standing and then got everything in focus and took a photo (see schematic introducing this section). In the photo below you can make out 12 through 16 cm which equals about 40mm. This is nowhere near 18mm and my "rounded" estimate is about a 1:2 magnification (40mm/18mm = 2.22).

Magnification
In "Part I" I stated the magnification was roughly 1:3, but that was including the vignette (5mm on either side). I repeated the test in 2x crop (digital tele-converter) mode and was able to fit apx. 26mm into the frame. This backs up the idea that including the vignette the frame can "hold" 52mm (26 x 2). 

2x in camera crop (digital tele-converter)
To summarize:
Working distance: 7cm
DOF: ~1cm
Magnification:
                        Entire frame (52mm) = 1:2.88 
                        Usable (40mm) = 1:2.22
                        2x crop (26mm) = 1:1.44

You can also see that if you turn on your digital tele-converter the vignette and color fringing become negligible. This helps with framing (which I discuss more of in "Part III")

II. Money Shot


Testing the sharpness of the BCLmacro was inspired by the awesome photo above which was taken by one of my Flickr contacts, Dave Elmore. For this shot he used the EM5 and Leica DG Macro Elmarit 45mm f/2.8 ASPH. I know its crazy to be comparing the modified BCL to the Leica, (because the latter is highly regarded and designed for macro, 14 times the price, and triple the effective focal length) but I was amazed at the level of detail captured by Dave and wanted to see how the BCLmacro measured up. For this test I taped my cleanest dollar bill (I only have 3 with me offshore haha) to the sketch book mentioned above and photographed under ambient lighting and after the addition of a small continuous light source (diffused flashlight). Photos were then taken at the following shutter speeds :
  • 1/2*effective focal length (1/60)
  • 1/effective focal length (1/30)
  • shutter speed at which auto iso=200 
Before I shot these, I lined up Mr. Washington's frame (the fancy area surrounding him) in the middle of the live view screen and then moved my magnification box (at 7x) around his eyes. After moving my camera into focus, I pressed the body against my desk to reduce vibration and depressed the shutter button. Also to counter camera shake I had "anti shock" set to 1/8 second. Below are the results of this test and for each of the shutter speeds I present the JPEG version of the unedited RAW file and a 100% near center crop (where my intentional focus was).


1. AMBIENT LIGHT

1/60 sec, iso 3200
1/60 sec: 100% near center crop
1/30 sec, iso 3200
1/30 sec: 100% near center crop
1.5 sec, iso 200
100% near center crop

2. ADDITIONAL CONTINUOUS SOURCE

1/60 sec, iso 200
1/60: 100% near center crop
1/30 sec, iso 1000
1/30: 100% near center crop

1/6 sec, iso 200
1/6 sec: 100% near center crop
These results overall seem fuzzy and the best out of the bunch IMO was the shot taken at 1/60 seconds with the addition of continuous light. I then took the photo at 1/250 shutter speed and iso 200 using the kit flash in manual mode (1/25) to see how the BCLmacro performed in optimal conditions.

3. FLASH 

1/250 sec, iso 200

1/250: 100% center crop
This photo was most definitely sharper than than any of the others. I actually took a series of photos with the flash ranging from 1/8 to 1/32 and chose this as the most correctly exposed. The next few photos represent:

A) George cropped and processed to taste:


 C) George cropped to represent dimensions of Dave's photo, equal to: 1452 x 1117


D) 100% crop of processed photo


Although Dave's photo was not uploaded to Flickr at full resolution, it does not represent a crop. There is no doubt that in print his photo would look a lot better than anything the BCLmacro would produce. However I think that this underdog proved to be a fairly sharp, especially if you are able to take photos with an increased shutter speed. For this I recommend using some sort of flash. Elegant descriptions about the benefits of using flash for macro photography can be found in several places on Robin Wong's blog in addition to many other sites on the internet. The use of flash for the BCL macro is actually essential in practice because of the short 7 mm working distance... but before I get ahead of myself and start talking about "real world use" I want bring up another feature of this lens that surprised me.

III. Pass the Butter


After assembling the BCLmacro, I accidentally took a photo of some of the super computers on board the vessel I am on. I was immediately amazed at the quality of bokeh my Frankenstein of a lens produced! I have dedicated the next portion of this article to giving examples of bokeh with the super computers as my subject. Photos are SOOC JPEGs that were taken using bulb mode on the OMD EM5. Using bulb mode allowed to to preserve an iso of 200 and stop the exposure when I saw fit.

1/10 sec, iso 200
1.6 sec, iso 200
2.1 sec, iso 200
5 sec, iso 200
I think if properly exposed then bokeh is nice and smooth. also since the aperture is fixed all light sources come out as perfect circles. The next two photos are 100% crops from the 1.6 sec exposure above and represent the best and worst "bokeh balls" in that frame.

Best

Worst
Looking at this example and realizing that this lens was produced to exhibit NO bokeh at all, I think that it gets at least an A- in this department. As with any macro lens, it is important that bokeh is smooth and does not distract from the subject that is in focus. Here are some examples of what to expect with the BCLmacro (photos are processed to my liking):






IV. Smells Fishy

Besides the heavy vignetting and color fringing, I wanted to end this post with a very short note on distortion. If you have already or are planning on dismantling your BCL you will notice that the original back end of the lens element is curved like a fisheye. This translates into the photos taken with this lens... especially when you are photographing straight lines. I think it adds to it's strange character, but if you are not a fan, luckily, the center is not impacted. Also, correcting in Lightroom is an option. 



100% crop for good measure and to keep you pixel peepers entertained ;)
Working with the BCLmacro has been a wonderful roller coaster of trial and error... and I have only been using it for 4 days! As with anything, the more time you spend with something the more you learn about its properties. This post is already far too long so the next post will feature some tips for use and of course, more example imaged from the BCLmacro. Thank you so very much for dropping by. You are a trooper if you read all this text and deserve an electronic salute =)  Please feel free to ask any questions about the modification or any part of this post. 

Sam D.
One more bokeh example because I couldn't help it




 
© 2012. Design by Main-Blogger - Blogger Template and Blogging Stuff